Can you go flat on one side after a mastectomy?

Yes. In a total (or simple) mastectomy, the entire breast, including the skin, areola, and nipple, is removed. This procedure leaves the chest flat on that side. Other types of mastectomies, like skin-sparing or nipple-sparing, are designed to preserve skin for reconstruction but going flat is a common and valid choice.

What are the benefits of going flat after mastectomy?

Choosing to go flat, often through a procedure called aesthetic flat closure, has several benefits. It typically involves a simpler surgery with a shorter recovery time compared to breast reconstruction. Post-operative care is often easier, allowing a quicker return to physical activities without adjusting to implants or tissue flaps.

What is the best way to care for mastectomy scars?

Proper scar care is crucial for healing. Key tips include: keeping the area clean and dry as directed by your surgeon, protecting scars from sun exposure to prevent darkening, staying hydrated, and eating a nutritious diet. Once cleared by your doctor, using silicone sheets or gel can help flatten scars, and gentle scar massage can improve flexibility and reduce tightness.

What are the chances of getting breast cancer after a double mastectomy?

The risk of developing breast cancer in the remaining chest tissue after a double mastectomy is very low. While a small amount of breast tissue can remain, the chance of a local recurrence is minimal. However, it's not zero. A 2024 study noted about a 7% risk of cancer in the opposite breast over 20 years for those with cancer in one breast. The decision should always be made in consultation with a medical team to weigh individual risks and benefits, especially considering factors like genetic mutations (e.g., BRCA genes).

Mastectomy Scars: A Comprehensive Healing Guide

A mastectomy scar is more than just a physical mark; it's a testament to a life-altering journey of survival, resilience, and transformation. Understanding what to expect physically, how to care for your body during recovery, and how to navigate the complex emotional landscape is essential for healing. This guide synthesizes expert medical advice, patient experiences, and advocacy insights to provide a comprehensive resource for anyone affected by mastectomy scars.

Understanding Mastectomy Scars: The Physical Healing Journey

Scars are a natural part of the body's healing process. After a mastectomy, your body produces a protein called collagen to repair the incision, creating a scar. The appearance of this scar evolves significantly over time and is influenced by genetics, skin tone, surgical technique, and aftercare.

What to Expect as Your Scar Heals

The healing process is a gradual one, and patience is key.

Initially: In the first few weeks and months, scars often appear red, pink, raised, and may feel tender or tight. According to Medical News Today, most scars look worse before they get better, so this initial appearance is normal.
Over Time: As the months and years pass, the scar will typically flatten, soften, and fade to a lighter, less noticeable color. The entire maturation process can take up to two years.

The final scar can have a puckered or uneven appearance, and some people may experience changes in pigmentation, with the scar becoming either darker (hyperpigmentation) or lighter (hypopigmentation) than the surrounding skin.

Factors That Influence Scar Appearance

Several factors can affect how your scar heals and its final look:

Surgical Technique: The surgeon's skill in placing and closing the incision plays a significant role.
Post-Op Complications: Issues like infection can negatively impact healing.
Genetics and Skin Type: Some individuals, particularly those with more melanin in their skin, may be more prone to developing thicker, raised scars like keloids.
Sun Exposure: UV rays can permanently darken a healing scar, making it more prominent.
Lifestyle: Smoking can slow the healing process and worsen a scar's appearance.

Types of Mastectomies and Their Resulting Scars

The location and size of your scar are primarily determined by the type of mastectomy you have. Surgeons aim to remove the cancerous tissue effectively while considering the aesthetic outcome, whether you choose reconstruction or to go flat.

Partial Mastectomy (Lumpectomy): Removes the tumor and a small margin of surrounding tissue, leaving a smaller, linear scar that is sometimes hidden in the crease under the breast or around the areola.
Total (Simple) Mastectomy: Removes the entire breast, nipple, and areola, typically resulting in a horizontal or diagonal scar across the chest.
Modified Radical Mastectomy: In addition to the breast tissue, lymph nodes in the armpit are removed. This can result in a larger scar that extends from the chest towards the armpit.
Skin-Sparing Mastectomy: Preserves most of the breast skin, creating an "envelope" for immediate reconstruction. The scar is often smaller and placed around the areola.
Nipple-Sparing Mastectomy: Preserves the nipple and areola, with incisions often made on the side of the breast or in the crease underneath, making the scar less visible.

The Rise of Aesthetic Flat Closure (AFC)

A growing number of people are choosing to "go flat" after a mastectomy, forgoing reconstruction. This has given rise to a specific surgical goal known as Aesthetic Flat Closure (AFC). AFC is more than just closing the incision; it's a reconstructive procedure recognized by the National Cancer Institute to create a smooth, contoured chest wall.

Advocacy groups like Not Putting on a Shirt have been instrumental in educating patients about AFC. Achieving a good result involves specific techniques to remove excess skin and fat, preventing issues like "dog ears" (puckering at the ends of the scar) and concavity (a scooped-out appearance).

Different incision patterns for aesthetic flat closure Image Source: Not Putting on a Shirt, illustrating various scar patterns for aesthetic flat closure.

Unfortunately, some patients experience "flat denial," where their request for AFC is not honored by surgeons. Advocacy research shows that this is a significant predictor of dissatisfaction with surgical outcomes. It is crucial to have an open conversation with your surgeon about your aesthetic goals to ensure your choices are respected.

Caring for Your Mastectomy Scars at Home

Proper care can significantly improve scar healing, comfort, and appearance. Always follow your surgeon's specific post-operative instructions first.

Essential Scar Care Tips

Keep it Clean and Dry: In the early stages, follow your surgical team's wound care protocol precisely.
Protect From the Sun: Shield your scar from direct sunlight for at least the first year. Use high-SPF sunscreen or protective clothing to prevent permanent darkening.
Moisturize: Once the incision has fully closed and your surgeon gives the okay, keep the skin hydrated with a gentle, fragrance-free moisturizer.
Consider Silicone: Silicone sheets or gels are widely recommended to help flatten, soften, and fade scars.
Gentle Scar Massage: After getting approval from your healthcare provider, gentle massage can be incredibly beneficial. As explained by experts at Breast Cancer Rehab, massage helps improve circulation, increase flexibility, and break down dense scar tissue, which can relieve tightness.

Beyond the Surface: Long-Term Physical Complications

Mastectomy scars can sometimes lead to long-term physical issues that affect comfort and mobility.

Chronic Pain and Nerve Issues: Scar tissue can feel tight and restrictive. Nerve damage during surgery is common, leading to numbness across the chest, tingling, itching, or sharp pains, a condition known as Post-Mastectomy Pain Syndrome.
Restricted Movement: Inflexible scar tissue can adhere to the underlying muscle, leading to shoulder stiffness and a limited range of motion.
Cording (Axillary Web Syndrome): Some people develop tight, rope-like structures under the skin of the armpit that can extend down the arm, causing pain and restricting movement. Physical therapy is key to managing this.
Lymphedema: The removal of lymph nodes can lead to a buildup of lymph fluid, causing swelling in the arm, hand, or chest wall on the affected side.

The Emotional and Psychological Journey

The emotional impact of mastectomy scars is as significant as the physical one. It's a journey of adaptation that involves body image, identity, and social acceptance.

Body Image, Grief, and Identity

A mastectomy fundamentally alters one's body, which can trigger a grieving process for the body that was and challenge one's sense of self, femininity, and sexuality. As research into the psychological adaptation highlights, this can be a "painful experience of body deconstruction." Allowing yourself time and space to process these feelings with support from therapists, support groups, or trusted loved ones is a vital part of healing.

From Scars to Symbols of Strength

Many survivors find ways to reclaim their bodies and redefine their relationship with their scars. This shift in perspective is a powerful part of the healing process.

Celebrities like Olivia Munn and Linda Evangelista have shared their experiences, helping to destigmatize mastectomy scars. After receiving a positive response to a Skims campaign that showed her scars, Munn revealed she stopped laser treatments, stating, "Now these scars... I’m proud of them now. They’re not something that I wanna cover up as much anymore."

Similarly, supermodel Linda Evangelista, who has faced breast cancer twice, told PEOPLE magazine that friends made her feel beautiful after seeing her scars for the first time. She has come to see them as "trophies."

!Photo of a woman with mastectomy scars smiling and embracing her body Acceptance and pride are powerful parts of the emotional healing journey.

For some, reclaiming their body takes an artistic form. Mastectomy tattoos are a growing trend, allowing individuals to transform their scars into beautiful works of art. This can range from restorative 3D nipple tattoos to elaborate decorative pieces that cover the chest, turning a reminder of trauma into a symbol of personal strength and beauty.

Professional Treatments for Scar Revision

If the appearance or physical sensation of your scar is causing distress, several professional treatments are available. According to BreastCancer.org, options may include:

Laser Therapy: Can help reduce redness and improve the texture of scar tissue.
Microneedling: Aims to stimulate new collagen production to smooth the scar's appearance.
Steroid Injections: Can help flatten and reduce itching in hypertrophic or keloid scars.
Surgical Scar Revision: A plastic surgeon can surgically remove the old scar and re-close the incision with techniques aimed at creating a less noticeable scar.

Your mastectomy scar is a permanent part of your story. Whether you see it as a battle wound, a trophy, or simply a part of your new body, the journey to healing and acceptance is uniquely yours. By arming yourself with knowledge, practicing self-compassion, and seeking support, you can navigate this path with strength and confidence.

Mastectomy Scars: A Survivor's Guide to Healing, Appearance, and Emotional Well-being

Key points